Peanut Butter Pie + Brownies = Sinful
That’s exactly what this pie is, brownies baked inside of a pie crust the topped with peanut butter pie filling. I added more whipped cream to the top because I figured, hey, if I’m going to go this far I may as well go all the way.
Easy. Impressive. Make ahead. Uncomplicated.
I knew when I saw this recipe that I would be making it. I knew you would love it, I knew my family would love it, I knew that I had to make it in time for Thanksgiving so that if anyone needed to take a dessert somewhere they would have time to gather the ingredients. I think that if you have ever been labeled “The One That Doesn’t Bake” you should make this pie and impress the socks off of your guests/hosts.
I found the recipe here. I made some modifications to the recipe and used my favorite pie crust and I used my favorite brownies. You can also use store bought pie crust and boxed brownies and this will be just as fabulous. Use what you are comfortable with!
Get your pie crust into the pan.
Make your brownies and pour them into your shell. If you are using my recipe, only put half in there. I did all of them and it was too much. If you are using a mix, get one that is for a 9×9 pan. Place it into a 350 degree oven for about 2025 minutes, or until it is set.

It’ll look like this if you use the whole recipe. This is 9″ deep dish pie plate, so it wasn’t quite full. Almost, but not quite. At this point you are going to stash it in the fridge until it is completely cool.

When it is cool, mix 1 (8 oz) package of cream cheese, 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter and 1 cup powdered sugar together. Mix in 1 (8 oz) tub of whipped topping that has been thawed and spread it on top of the brownies. I chose to add half of another carton of whipped topping to mine, just to make it truly spectacular!

And there it is! I told you it was easy.

This would be a great addition toThanksgiving or Christmas (or any get together for that matter!)
I’ve linked up this recipe here at Tidy Mom as part of her Love The Pie linky party! Go look at all the other wonderful looking pies! 🙂

5 comments on “Mile High Peanut Butter Pie

  1. Danyel Wolf

    OH MY GOODNESS! I am gonna have to try this!

  2. Connie @ Rookie Foodie

    That sounds unbelievable! I have to make this!

    Thank you!

  3. TidyMom

    Looks DELICIOUS…… can’t go wrong with peanut butter!!

    Thanks for sharing and linking up!

  4. TidyMom

    Sinful is the PERFECT way to describe this pie!!! Thanks so much for sharing and linking up!!

    and guess what? you were a winner!!!……..check your email! ♥

  5. k.j.

    You could also swirl the peanut butter/cream cheese mixture into the unbaked brownie batter mix. then bake. I’ve been making these with much success.

Comments are closed.